8 results

Where did the Snapper go? Determining factors influencing the recovery of Snapper stocks on the west coast of Australia

Project number: 2018-050
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $332,535.00
Principal Investigator: Gary Jackson
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 29 Apr 2019 - 30 Jun 2021
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

Ensuring that connectivity and stock dynamics are well understood is crucial to determining the appropriate scale for fisheries management and assessment.
There is strong industry and management interest in determining the extent to which connectivity and stock dynamics of snapper along the west coast might have changed over time reflecting changes in environmental conditions and stock abundance.
There is a need to reassess the most appropriate scale for management of the snapper resource in WA under the new Aquatic Resources and Management Act.
There is a need to evaluate whether active-acoustic methods can improve capacity to monitor the spatial distribution and abundance of snapper in key spawning aggregations and whether these methods are complementary to the existing approaches used to assess snapper stocks in the GCB and WCB and elsewhere in Australia.

Objectives

1. Improve understanding of snapper stock connectivity between the Gascoyne and West Coast Bioregions using high-resolution genomic techniques
2. Identify evidence of key sources of recruitment to snapper stocks in the Gascoyne and West Coast Bioregions using otolith microchemistry
3. Quantify snapper egg and larval dispersal between the Gascoyne and West Coast Bioregions using high-resolution ocean circulation modelling
4. Evaluate the use of active acoustic methods for monitoring the distribution and abundance of snapper in spawning aggregations
5. Investigate possible changes in key biological parameters in snapper in the Gascoyne and West Coast Bioregions in relation to changes in environmental conditions and stock abundance

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-925415-01-8
Authors: Gary Jackson David Fairclough Emily Fisher Yasha Hetzel Mirjam Van Der Mheen Ben Scoulding Bronwyn Gillanders Patrick Reis-Santos Luciano B. Beheregaray Jonathan Sandoval-Castillo and Matias Braccini
Final Report • 2023-05-02 • 9.74 MB
2018-050-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report describes a collaborative project focused on Snapper (Chrysophrys auratus) carried out between 2018 and 2021 by researchers from the Western Australian Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD), Flinders University, University of Adelaide, University of Western Australia, and CSIRO. The project was co-funded by the Fisheries Research and Development Corporation and had three key aims, which were motivated by questions raised by commercial fishers in the Gascoyne and West Coast bioregions of Western Australia, about C. auratus stock structure in relation to current fishery management boundaries and the methodologies used to assess these Snapper stocks.

 

Firstly, the biological connectivity of C. auratus in waters offshore of Shark Bay (in the Gascoyne Coast Bioregion) and to the south off an area between Kalbarri and Geraldton (in the West Coast Bioregion) were investigated using population genomics, otolith chemistry and larval dispersal modelling. These studies identified, for the first time, nursery grounds inside Shark Bay that are attributable to the Gascoyne oceanic Snapper stock, confirmed the larval transport pathways linking these with known spawning grounds around islands off Shark Bay and commenced the development of a recruitment index for this stock. 

 

Secondly, a novel fishery-independent survey method, combining acoustics (sonar) with underwater cameras, termed acouptics, was trialled for monitoring C. auratus stocks off Shark Bay. The study has shown that these active acoustic methods can be used to monitor Snapper aggregations and estimate numbers of fish/biomass, providing a potential addition to the future Snapper assessment toolkit.

 

Thirdly, this project explored if there had been any changes in the biological characteristics of C. auratus in oceanic waters of the Gascoyne Coast Bioregion and northern West Coast Bioregion over the past 30 years. The study demonstrated changes in maturity of Snapper in the Gascoyne, with the updated parameters used to inform the most recent (2022) assessment of this C. auratus stock.

 

The outcomes of this project will provide the basis for a review of stock assessment approaches and management arrangements for C. auratus on the West coast of Australia. Outcomes of the acouptics work provides a conceptual basis for application in C. auratus assessment research elsewhere in Australia and New Zealand.

Environment
PROJECT NUMBER • 2004-051
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Management and monitoring of fish spawning aggregations within the West Coast Bio-region of Western Australia

Many strategies have evolved among fishes to maximise spawning success. One of the most striking of these is aggregation spawning, in which individuals group together, often at predictable times and locations in order to reproduce (cf. a school, which refers to a group of non-spawning fish)....
ORGANISATION:
Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA

Comparing conventional ‘social-based’, and alternative output-based, management models for recreational finfish fisheries using Shark Bay pink snapper as a case study

Project number: 2003-066
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $204,735.00
Principal Investigator: Gary Jackson
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 29 Jun 2003 - 16 Feb 2006
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

The Ministerial-working group has recommended a package of measures aimed at recovering spawning biomass of the inner gulf snapper stocks to take effect in 2003. In the eastern gulf, in the first year following the fishery’s re-opening, a combination of daily bag limit, ‘slot’ size limit, and an extended seasonal closure will be used in an attempt to limit the catch to 12–15 tonnes. Although 3 tonnes has been allocated to the commercial sector (based on catch history), no decision has been made in relation to allocation of the remaining 12 tonnes (approximately 4000 individual fish) between the local charter sector and independent recreational fishers. This conventional management approach may achieve the objective of sustainability but a seasonal closure (to protect spawning fish) will alter the nature of the recreational fishery and is unlikely to be popular with many visiting fishers. To overcome this, the working group has agreed to trial an alternative, output-based approach in the eastern gulf in 2004 that would allow some snapper fishing during the peak winter period while still meeting sustainability objectives. A unique opportunity therefore exists, to develop and assess an alternative management approach, i.e. capable of constraining the recreational snapper catch to a sustainable level while preserving the seasonal aspect of the fishery. The daily egg production method, used to provide estimates of adult stock size since 1997, requires considerable resources (particularly in the laboratory) and is therefore relatively expensive. There is a need to investigate the potential of an alternative, independent measure of stock size that may be incorporated into a future research framework. At a broader scale, there is a need to compare the relative advantages and disadvantages of output-based (manage to predetermined catch) and more conventional models for the management of recreational and multi-sector finfish fisheries with a major recreational component. Such information will allow improved decision-making around the choice of research and management tools for similar marine fisheries elsewhere.

Objectives

1. To assess an alternative output-based management model capable of constraining the pink snapper catch within sustainable limits in the inner gulf of Shark Bay
2. To develop an alternative measure of stock size for future use in management of the fishery
3. To provide a detailed comparison of the relative advantages and disadvantages of output- and input-based models for the management of key recreational, and multi- sector finfish fisheries, using the Shark Bay inner gulf pink snapper fishery as case study

Final report

ISBN: 1-877098-78-7
Author: Gary Jackson
Final Report • 2006-10-10
2003-066-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study has provided for the first time in Australia, an empirical comparison of different management models with a recreational marine finfish fishery.  A TAC-based system was introduced for pink snapper in the inner gulfs of Shark Bay for the first time in 2003-2005, to explicitly manage levels of recreational catch. We developed an alternative, output-based management model - limited issue of management-tags allocated to recreational fishers via a lottery system - to ensure that the annual catch of pink snapper in the Freycinet Estuary was no more than the TAC of 5 tonne per year.  This tag-based system was assessed against a range of criteria - capacity to limit the pink snapper catch, social equity, fisher acceptance, compliance and cost - and against more conventional management used in the Eastern Gulf and Denham Sound.  The tag-based system in the Freycinet Estuary was effective at limiting the recreational catch as was the four month spawning closure in the Eastern Gulf.  The management-tags allowed recreational fishers in the Freycinet Estuary to chose when they landed their pink snapper.  In contrast, the extensive closure in the Eastern Gulf prevented fishers from retaining snapper during the traditionally most popular winter period.  Although management-tags were not initially popular with recreational fishers, an increase in lottery applications between 2003 and 2005 indicates their increased acceptance.  The study has provided a comparison of two methods of estimating population size of pink snapper in the Eastern Gulf; population estimates from tagging were not significantly different from those obtained using the daily egg production method.  The study has also provided a model-based assessment of the status of each inner Shark Bay pink snapper stock using data collected during the project.  The study has shown that quantifiable management objectives were unclear or absent in many of Australia’s key marine recreational fisheries.  Output from the project will be of interest to stakeholders involved in the management of the inner Shark Bay recreational fishery and more broadly to fishery managers involved with snapper and other important recreational finfish species in Australia and possibly New Zealand.  Results from this project were used as the basis for developing management strategies for inner Shark Bay pink snapper stocks for the three year period 2006-2008. 
Environment
PROJECT NUMBER • 2003-052
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Spatial scales of exploitation among populations of demersal scalefish: implications for wetline management

West Australian dhufish is endemic to shelf waters of south-western Western Australia (WA). In contrast, snapper (known as "pink snapper" in WA) has a continuous distribution around the southern coastline of mainland Australia and in New Zealand. Dhufish and snapper are the two most important...
ORGANISATION:
Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA

Identifying nursery areas used by inner bay and oceanic snapper stocks in the Shark Bay region, in relation to the effect of prawn trawling on inner bay snapper stocks

Project number: 2001-061
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $97,634.00
Principal Investigator: Dan Gaughan
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 29 Jun 2001 - 30 Apr 2004
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

There is an urgent need to clarify whether the juvenile snapper taken in the Denham Sound sector of the Shark Bay Prawn Trawl Fishery recruit to the recreationally fished, depleted western gulf of inner Shark Bay stock or the sustainably (predominantly commercially) fished oceanic stock. This information is needed to ascertain whether changes to the management arrangements to the trawl fishery would significantly benefit the threatened inner bay snapper stocks. Successful resolution of this contentious issue (and management change if warranted) in the sensitive World heritage Area will refocus public debate onto the more critical issue of overall resource sustainability.

Objectives

1. To establish whether trace element and isotope composition in otoliths of juvenile (0+) pink snapper is diagnostic of location on a transect from inner Shark Bay, through Denham Sound, to the oceanic waters.
2. To analyse cores of otoliths of adult snapper from the ocean and Denham Sound stocks, to establish the location of the nursery grounds for each stock
3. To evaluate Laser Abalation, Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry as a tool for fish stock assessment and movement studies by comparison with concurrent stable isotope ratio and previous whole otolith trace element studies on Shark Bay snapper.

Final report

ISBN: 1-887098-15-9
Author: Dan Gaughan
Final Report • 2004-04-07 • 2.28 MB
2001-061-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study examined two aspects of the chemical composition of snapper otoliths from Shark Bay Western Australia as an aid to determining the spatial relationship among juveniles and to better understand the spatial relationships between juveniles and adults.  Otoliths were collected from juvenile snapper in Denham Sound and Freycinet Estuary in the western gulf of Shark Bay.  In order to also compare otolith chemistry for juveniles from outer Shark Bay to that from the western gulf, adult snapper were collected from these locations and the portion of their otoliths corresponding to an age <1 year (i.e. young juveniles) were analysed.  As well as the two western gulf sites already mentioned, the oceanic samples were obtained from Koks Island and Cape Inscription.
Environment

Quantification of changes in recreational catch and effort on inner Shark Bay snapper species following implementation of responsive management measures

Project number: 2000-139
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $49,125.00
Principal Investigator: Neil Sumner
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 5 Sep 2000 - 4 Aug 2003
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The size of the recreational catch for pink snapper together with information on the stock size from the egg production method (separate study funded by Fisheries WA) is required to estimate the proportion of the stock taken by recreational fishers over a one year period. This important information will be used to assess the sustainability of present levels of recreational fishing and to determine whether on not further management measured are required.

The Gascoyne Region Working Group has noted that a major obstacle to the resolution of fishery management and resource sharing issues in the region is the scarcity of data on recreational catches and activity. Additional monitoring beyond the previous creel survey, funded by Fisheries WA, which finished in March 1999 is required to estimate changes to the total catch, catch rates, size composition and mortality of these and other exploited marine species. This information, together with other studies funded by Fisheries WA to estimate the size of the pink snapper stocks, is required to develop strategies for the management of recreational fishing in Shark Bay.

An estimate of the recreational catch, fishing effort, catch rates and location caught for black snapper is required for the related FRDC project "The age growth and reproductive biology and stock assessment of black snapper, Lethrinus laticaudis in Shark Bay, WA" (FRDC 99/152).

Objectives

1. To estimate the proportion of pink snapper stock harvested by recreational fishers using results from this creel survey and the egg production method survey.
2. To provide an estimate of the recreational catch of all species including fish (esp. pink snapper and black snapper), sharks, crustaceans and molluscs in the Shark Bay region.
3. To provide an estimate of the recreational fishing effort in the Shark Bay region.
4. To assess the re-direction of fishing effort after changes to the management regulations.
5. To provide the length frequency of pink snapper, black snapper and other prime species kept by recreational fishers.

Final report

ISBN: 1-877098-05-1
Author: Neil Sumner
Final Report • 2003-05-05 • 1,004.14 KB
2000-139-DLD.pdf

Summary

A 12-month creel survey of recreational boat-based fishing in Shark Bay, Western Australia was conducted between May 2001 and April 2002 to estimate the catch of pink snapper.  During the survey 431 boat crews were interviewed at public boat ramps of which 414 had been fishing.

The information was required to assess the sustainability of pink snapper stocks at present levels of recreational fishing and to determine the most appropriate management measures required to keep recreational catches within management targets.

Pink snapper were predominantly caught from Freycinet Estuary and landed at Nanga (17.5 tonnes) or Tamala Station (4.7 tonnes). Pink snapper caught from Freycinet Reach were landed at Denham (7.5 tonnes). Catches from these stocks have decreased from 25.7 tonnes landed at Nanga and 12.2 tonnes landed at Denham estimated by a survey conducted in 1998-99 (Sumner et al., 2002).

The impact of revised management measures introduced in the western gulf to reduce the recreational catch of pink snapper was predicted using catch and effort data collected from surveys completed prior to their introduction. The revised management measures included a minimum size limit of 500 mm, bag limit of two, a limit of one fish over 700 mm per person and a partial closure to fishing for pink snapper in Freycinet Estuary (south of Goulet Bluff) between 15 August and 30 September during the spawning period. The predictions were found to be accurate when compared to catches estimated from a creel survey following the introduction of new regulations.

As predicted, despite the introduction of the new management measures, the estimated catch of pink snapper in Freycinet Estuary was four times the management target catch of five tonnes. In Freycinet Reach, the new management measures reduced the landed catch by one quarter with a corresponding increase in the number of undersize fish released. The effectiveness of the revised management measures varied between Freycinet Estuary and Freycinet Reach due to the different size composition of the recreational catch of pink snapper at these locations.

The limited effectiveness of the recently introduced management measures indicates that small and vulnerable stocks, such as the inner gulf pink snapper stocks in Shark Bay, cannot be effectively managed using standard techniques such as size and bag limits. Traditional recreational management methods based on size and bag limits did not reduce the catch in Freycinet Estuary to a sustainable level. Furthermore, due to the minimum size limit, large numbers of pink snapper are being caught and subsequently released particularly in the Freycinet Reach. Consequently, the mortality of fish caught and subsequently released is of concern (This is the focus of another project FRDC 2000/194 “Investigating survival of released undersized west coast reef fish”). These problems will provide challenges for the management of this and other similar recreational fisheries.

Keywords: Recreational Fishing, Pink Snapper, Shark Bay, Creel Survey

Minimising the cost of future stock monitoring, and assessment of the potential for increased yields from the oceanic snapper, Pagrus auratus, stock off Shark Bay

Project number: 2000-138
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $89,792.00
Principal Investigator: Dan Gaughan
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 5 Sep 2000 - 14 Apr 2005
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

A more precise stock assessment is needed for the Shark Bay Snapper Fishery in view of the wide confidence limits around the previous assessment in the mid 1980s. Assessment is needed now because of the increased level of recreational effort on the stock and the implication in the new management plan that the commercial TAC must be reduced to enable recreational catches to be included in an overall TAC. The material is available for a precise stock assessment but resources are required for working up the data and performing the stock assessment.
Knowledge of the degree of variability in annual recruitment is required to assess the feasibility of a cost effective constant TAC management policy for the future.
Market preferences for fish of particular sizes, and the minimum legal length, can result in significant discarding. The mortality of these discarded fish and effects on the stocks need to be factored into TAC calculations.
A minimal cost method needs to be devised for routine future monitoring of the fishery.

Objectives

1. Estimate annual recruitments and fishing mortalities in the snapper fishery throughout the 1980s and 1990s.
2. Assess the risks to the snapper stock of a range of annual commercial and recreational catches, taking into account the mortality of discarded fish and variability in recruitment.
3. Devise a minimal cost method for future monitoring of the snapper fishery.

Final report

ISBN: 1-877098-69-8
Author: Dan Gaughan
Final Report • 2005-03-16 • 1.84 MB
2000-138-DLD.pdf

Summary

The investment in this project has resulted in a substantially more extensive set of age composition data than would have otherwise been possible.  This in turn has underpinned stock assessment modeling that has provided the basis for determining that the commercial fishery for snapper in Shark Bay needed a substantial decrease the total allowable catch.  The modeling was able to determine that the stock was at a low size following a period of low recruitment during the late 1990s.  The suspected low recruitment, evident once the age date were collated, and anticipated negative effects on the stock were both quantitatively described; this mathematical treatment has been a critical input to the series of management meetings for the fishery.  The significant outcome for this project was that there was no potential to increase yields in the fishery.  The fishery is considered to be sustainable since the reductions in catch were instigated.  The effort and catch levels typical of the 1990s were curtailed to allow the stock to recover – this ongoing maintenance of the fishery at a level that will allow the stock to increase in size, rather than implementing a complete closure associated with a more seriously depleted stock of snapper, is directly attributable to the research undertaken in this project.  The occurrence of infrequent but drastic recruitment failure, as demonstrated in this project, dictates that ongoing monitoring of age-composition will be required to manage this fishery.

Keywords: pink snapper, recruitment, age-structured model, cohort analysis, risk assessment.

View Filter