142 results

Can commercial harvest of long-spined sea urchins reduce the impact of urchin grazing on abalone and lobster fisheries?

Project number: 2013-026
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $297,908.54
Principal Investigator: Craig Mundy
Organisation: University of Tasmania (UTAS)
Project start/end date: 31 Aug 2013 - 16 Oct 2016
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The long-spined sea urchin Centrostrephanus rodgersii has gradually increased in extent and biomass on the East coast of Tasmania over the past three decades. Options for direct and indirect intervention are being considered to limit numbers of this urchin to that required to minimise the destruction of the kelp and understory habitat essential for other benthic species such as abalone and rock lobster. Over the past two years a fledgling urchin harvest industry has developed in Tasmania, with the potential for market demands to create a significant fishery in terms of harvest biomass. Whether harvesting of urchins is beneficial (synergistic) to existing fisheries needs to be determined to inform development of a Harvest Strategy of all species reliant on healthy shallow (20m) sub-tidal ecosystems. The efficacy of commercial urchin harvesting as a ‘control tool’ is dependent on the degree of spatial overlap with other fisheries (co-dependent on habitat), the capacity of urchin harvesting to minimise localised destructive grazing, and, whether the urchin harvest is economically sustainable given the practical limitations of harvesting at depth.

Objectives

1. Determine spatial location and extent of overlap between Centrostephanus and existing fisheries
2. Application of coastal exposure indices for identifying potential urchin harvest locations
3. Determine dive profile strategies to enable safe harvest of urchins at depths greater than 15m

Final report

Authors: Keane J.P. Mundy C. Porteus M. Johnson O.
Final Report • 2019-03-01 • 1.88 MB
2013-026-DLD.pdf

Summary

At low-levels of exploitation, commercial harvesting of long-spined sea urchins was found to prevent increase in urchin density. Adjacent unfished locations experienced an increase in both urchin density and grazed area over the 2014 – 2016 study period. Research sampling of populations remaining on reefs after fishing also found that mean urchin Test diameter and urchin age was smaller and younger respectively than on nearby unfished reefs, further supporting there is a measurable effect of urchin fishing on urchin populations even at low exploitation rates. These results demonstrate a clear potential for urchin fishing to reduce destructive grazing by urchins, or at least prevent further expansion of existing grazed areas even under a regime of low
fishing pressure.
 
The Tasmanian commercial fishery of long-spined urchin either directly overlaps or is immediately adjacent to commercially fished abalone reefs. As the presence of barrens has a clear negative association with abalone abundance, the potential for urchin fishing to lower urchin densities in key reef habitats highlights the importance of an ongoing long-spined urchin fishery for protecting key abalone fishing grounds (recreational and commercial). The ability to capture fine-scale spatial data on both urchin and abalone fisheries was critical to evaluating the potential for urchin fishing to benefit the abalone fishery. A long-term strategy for fine-scale data collection using passive GPS and Depth data loggers will be fundamental to ongoing assessment of the benefits of urchin fishing to the abalone fishery, but also to the broader users of shallow coastal reef systems in Eastern Australia.There is also the potential for positive-feedback loops from urchin fishing, with reduction in densities increasing roe production and output, and therefore ensure that the industry can remain economically sustainable.
 
Cartographic Exposure Index software developed during this project showed some capacity to identify coastlines at risk to destructive grazing, but further data collection to underpin the predictive model is required. Production of a high-resolution bathymetric map of key coastal reefs is considered to be a high priority for ongoing spatial mapping and analysis of the expansion of the urchin fishery and its consequent effects on urchin density.
 
There is a clear benefit to the urchin fishers if they switch from compressed air to using Nitrox gas for diving safety and access to greater reef area. Current beach price and likely decline in catch rates as the fishery expands however, will mean that investment in Nitrox based breathing systems may be economically marginal. From a health perspective, a switch to Nitrox while retaining the current bottom time would have clear safety benefits.
 
This study demonstrated positive benefits for abalone habitat at very-low urchin exploitation levels, with the extent and spatial magnitude of benefits expected to rapidly increase with increasing urchin exploitation. It is unlikely that commercial harvesting will lead to eradication of the long-spined sea urchin, but there is clear potential for commercial fishing to be a primary contributor to mitigating the destructive grazing of this species.

Aquatic Animal Health Subprogram: Determination of susceptibility of various abalone species and populations to the various known AbHV genotypes

Project number: 2013-001
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $207,118.00
Principal Investigator: Serge Corbeil
Organisation: CSIRO Australian Animal Health Laboratory
Project start/end date: 30 Jun 2013 - 2 Aug 2015
Contact:
FRDC

Need

With the emergence of AVG in in Victorian abalone in 2005/6, the subsequent discovery of several genetic variants of the causative agent, abalone herpesvirus (AbHV), associated with disease outbreaks in Tasmanian processing plants, and apparent variations in AbHV pathogenicity observed in different abalone species, there is the need to understand what factors promote disease in infected hosts. This project aims to address this knowledge gap and is relevant to all jurisdictions with abalone fisheries. Access to biosecure aquarium facilities, major abalone species and all known AbHV genotypes provides CSIRO-AAHL with a unique capability to investigate what factors influence disease outcomes following infection, including the nature of the AbHV genotype as well as abalone species or origins from locations spanning the primary wild fisheries in Victoria, Tasmania and South Australia. An improved understanding of the susceptibility of of abalone of different species and origins to infection by the various AbHV genotypes, and of whether different genotypes vary in their potential to transition from sub-clinical infection to acute disease is important for instructing fisheries and aquaculture policies and strategies to avoid disease, especially in aquaculture and abalone processing facilities. This project addresses specific priorities detailed in the current FRDC Aquatic Animal Health Subprogram R&D Plan (viz. 6.2.1 Nature of disease and host-pathogen interaction), priorities identified in the National Abalone Health Work Plan developed by a committee of national representatives following the second Abalone Virus Scientific and Management Forum held in Melbourne in 2007, and FRDC’s 2013 Annual Competitive Round Call for Expressions Of Interest (viz. Determining risk factors for AVG).

Objectives

1. Determine the susceptibility of greenlip, blacklip, hybrid and other readily available abalone species to abalone herpesvirus (AbHV) genotypes
2. Determine the complete genome sequences for AbHV Tas3 and Tas4 to gain insights into how and over what timeframe they have arisen, whether genetic recombination is contributing to this variation and which genome regions might affect virulence, as well as instructing on how diagnostic methods for their detection and diffferentiation can be refined.

Final report

Authors: Serge Corbeil Lynette M Williams Jeff A Cowley Nick JG Moody and Mark StJ Crane

Seafood CRC: China trade project officer

Project number: 2012-761
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $15,596.23
Principal Investigator: Steven G. Gill
Organisation: Gill Consulting
Project start/end date: 16 Sep 2012 - 16 Apr 2013
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The consultants selected to deliver the projects (KGA for project 2012/704 and China Policy for project 2012/705) do not currently have existing networks in the seafood export industry. This project is required to:
• Provide support to the consultants and assist with the two way transfer of knowledge between the industry and the consultants.

• Establish and provide ongoing support for an industry reference group as well as facilitate consultation the broader catching and export sector.

• Support communication and extension activity to borader SRL, WRL and ACA members.

Objectives

1. Provide support for project consultants, industry reference group and broader industry to achieve effective delivery of projects 2012/704 and 2012/705

Seafood CRC: quantifying physiological and behavioural responses of cultured abalone to stress events

Project number: 2012-708
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $102,545.04
Principal Investigator: Peter B. Frappell
Organisation: University of Tasmania (UTAS)
Project start/end date: 30 Sep 2012 - 30 Dec 2013
Contact:
FRDC

Need

It is desirable for any primary producer to understand the health and welfare of their stock. This will ultimately enable optimal production and return on investment.

The challenge in any aquaculture system is ‘observing’ the physiological and behavioural responses associated with environment, production and other stressors; all factors that impact on the animal health and welfare and so overall production efficiency. Suboptimal health is often associated with culturing conditions, and this is predicted to become more prevalent and unpredictable with a changing climate. There is therefore an immediate and long-term need to overcome the 'observation' challenge.

How do we know if conditions are optimal, and the observed performance efficient and sustainable? Generally for aquaculture species, such as molluscs, it is through measurements of growth rate and survival, equating to biomass produced, rather than on metabolic and behaviour observations on the animal, that are difficult to observe and poorly understood. Therefore there is limited information available for optimising the commercial environment from the animal’s perspective.

Sub-optimal conditions lead to stress, and there are multiple (observed and unobserved) stressors or stress events within a commercial growout system, the impact of which on an abalone’s physiology is poorly understood. Measurement of an animal’s response to stress is usually retrospective of the event and via invasive sample collection (an additional stressor).

This proposal is taking advantage of the development of a new research tool (“biologger”) for the in-situ measurement of physiological and behavioural parameters to gain an understanding of the response of the abalone to a range of commonly experienced and predicted stressors in a commercial system. This research will provide knowledge for refining farm management protocols, and in the longer-term for developing real-time bio-monitoring of farm management protocols.

Objectives

1. To determine the physiological coping ranges and responses of temperate abalone to various environmental and production stressors measured under controlled laboratory conditions.
2. To attempt to monitor in-situ farmed temperate abalone under commercial conditions to identify and understand the key physiological and behavioural responses to a variety of production stessors
3. To develop preliminary algorithms to enable interpretation of data from biologgers in the context of physiological and behavioural response to identified stressors
4. To identify any potential applications of existing biologgers to improve current farm management protocols

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-4863-0403-5
Authors: Andrea Morash Katharina Alter Andrew Hellicar Sarah Andrewartha Peter Frappell & Nick Elliott
Final Report • 2015-04-05 • 1.03 MB
2012-708-DLD.pdf

Summary

It is desirable for any primary producer to understand the health and welfare of their stock. This will ultimately enable optimal production and return on investment. The challenge in any aquaculture system is ‘observing’ the physiological and behavioural responses associated with environment, production and other stressors; all factors that impact on the animal health and welfare and so overall production efficiency. Suboptimal health is often associated with culturing conditions, and this is predicted to become more prevalent and unpredictable with a changing climate. There is therefore an immediate and long-term need to overcome the 'observation' challenge.

How do we know if conditions are optimal, and the observed performance efficient and sustainable? Generally for aquaculture species, such as molluscs, it is through measurements of growth rate and survival, equating to biomass produced, rather than on metabolic and behaviour observations on the animal, that are difficult to observe and poorly understood. Therefore there is limited information available for optimising the commercial environment from the animal’s perspective. Sub-optimal conditions lead to stress, and there are multiple (observed and unobserved) stressors or stress events within a commercial growout system, the impact of which on an abalone’s physiology is poorly understood. Measurement of an animal’s response to stress is usually retrospective of the event and via invasive sample collection (an additional stressor).

This project took advantage of the development of a new research tool (“biologger”) for the in-situ measurement of physiological and behavioural parameters to gain an understanding of the response of the abalone to a range of commonly experienced and predicted stressors in a commercial system. This research will provide knowledge for refining farm management protocols, and in the longer-term for developing real-time bio-monitoring of farm management protocols.

This project aimed to:

  1. Determine the physiological coping ranges and responses of temperate abalone to various environmental and production stressors measured under controlled laboratory conditions.
  2. Attempt to monitor in-situ farmed temperate abalone under commercial conditions to identify and understand the key physiological and behavioural responses to a variety of production stressors.
  3. Develop preliminary algorithms to enable interpretation of data from biologgers in the context of physiological and behavioural response to identified stressors.
  4. Identify any potential applications of existing biologgers to improve current farm management protocols.

Seafood CRC: China projects expenses - 2012/704 and 2012/705

Project number: 2012-705.20
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $10,468.23
Principal Investigator: Jayne M. Gallagher
Organisation: Seafood CRC Company Ltd
Project start/end date: 31 Dec 2012 - 29 Jun 2013
Contact:
FRDC

Need

This project is for expenses associated with CRC projects 2012/704 and 2012/705

Objectives

1. To enable industry attendance at the CRC China Projects Reference Group meetings

Seafood CRC: improving trade and market access to the People's republic of China for Australian rocklobster and abalone industries

Project number: 2012-705
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $31,238.64
Principal Investigator: Phillipa Jones
Organisation: China Policy
Project start/end date: 16 Sep 2012 - 29 Apr 2013
Contact:
FRDC
TAGS

Need

The Australian lobster industry has reported that the ongoing interruptions to trade between Hong Kong and mainland China have impacted on them through:
• Financial loss from seized products and lost payments
• Impact on fishers with lower beach prices
• Shipments on hold causing product losses
• Emergence (and disappearance) of transient buyers
• Requests to send shipments via Vietnam and Thailand.
Such disruptions are unpredictable and are not likely to cease. Consequently the risk to Australian exporters is likely to become untenable and the trade might cease or be significantly reduced, leading to enormous loss of capital value in the industries.

In the case of Australian Wild Abalone it is reported that all trade between Hong Kong and Shenzhen has ceased since the initial border disruption in November 2010. A delegation comprising Abalone exporters, CRC and ACA representatives visited China in November 2011 and were asked by their importers to help improve the trade and market access for Abalone directly into mainland China.

There needs to be improved understanding of the constraints to trade and the mechanisms available to remove them. This includes ensuring that Australia's government trade negotiation positions are robust and strategic, based on sound industry knowledge. Identification of the mechanisms to improve trade and market access and the supporting information needed to capitalise on them will be critical.

Objectives

1. To produce a report for SRL and WRL on how to pursue the development of direct trade routes for Australian rock lobster exports to mainland China

Seafood CRC: Industry strategies to support intergovernmental negotiations concerning the export of Australian Rocklobster and Abalone to China

Project number: 2012-704
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $138,129.08
Principal Investigator: Sam Guthrie
Organisation: Kreab Gavin Anderson
Project start/end date: 16 Sep 2012 - 30 Mar 2013
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Increasing direct trading arrangements would reduce the risks of financial loss and disruptions to trade and would also facilitate transparency along the value chain, provide opportunities for product promotion and enable industry to understand the purchase decisions of end users. However, within the industry there is some uncertainty and concern about how to achieve a transition to direct trade.

To facilitate this transition additional research is required on:

• The protocols, forms, customs clearance processes and costs for direct import into various cities within China.
• The legal and regulatory requirements, appropriate business structures and import quotas required for direct trade.
• Identification of the risks and benefits of direct trade for individual companies.
• Assessment of the short and long term impacts on existing Chinese importers and how they and their businesses will be affected by an increase in direct trade.

Facilitating the development of new relationships with importers willing to direct import into traditional markets and other regions within China.
Several Southern and Western Rock Lobster exporters have indicated a commitment to supporting pilot studies of direct trading activities.

Objectives

1. Produce a manual that provides key messages and a guide to constructive engagement between government and industry officials involved in Australia/China seafood trade negotiations.
2. Develop a series of options or recommendations on how the ACA, SRL and WRL could establish a program to provide ongoing intelligence and awareness of developments in China trade policy and input to Australian government negotiations with China

ACA IPA: Wild Harvest Abalone National RD&E Planning, Management and Oversight

Project number: 2012-404
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $411,844.00
Principal Investigator: Dean M. Lisson
Organisation: Abalone Council Australia Ltd (ACA)
Project start/end date: 8 Oct 2012 - 30 Jan 2018
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Commercial in confidence. To know more about this project please contact FRDC.

Objectives

Commercial in confidence

Tactical Research Fund: developing the decision process for setting the TAC for abalone in Victoria, particularly with reference to recovery of AVG-impacted reefs

Project number: 2012-236
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $85,000.00
Principal Investigator: Harry F. Peeters
Organisation: Western Abalone Divers Association (WADA)
Project start/end date: 30 Jun 2013 - 29 Jul 2014
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Abalone Viral Ganglioneuritis (AVG) was first observed causing catastrophic mortality of abalone in western Victoria during May 2006, and continued to spread. As a consequence, there was a large reduction in Total Allowable Catch with consequent reductions in GVP of the Industry and its profitability. Further, the AVG-related mortality led to great uncertainty about the status of the abalone populations (e.g. depletion) and its productive ability (e.g. catch). Populations affected by AVG were closed to fishing for 3-5 years, and have gradually been re-opened through a process involving fishery-independent abundance surveys, biomass estimates and structured fishing to deliver information about stocks. Combined with routine monitoring, a substantial amount of data has now been collected about the on-going recovery of abalone stocks to inform their management.

Prior to AVG, WADA developed a process for finer scale assessment and management advice for the fishery. Workshops with significant Industry input and consideration of fine scale stock assessment are now used in most state's abalone fishery. With the reestablishment of fishing in western Victoria, and greater information about the productive capacity of the stock, there is now a strong need to consolidate the data available and develop their interpretation as performance indicators for the fishery. An important component of this will include the use of the performance indicators in developing flexible decision criteria and investigating scenarios of recovery for the fishery from a population model, updating earlier scenarios generated prior to the resumption of fishing. The Victorian Central Zone fishery has also been impacted by AVG, and will also benefit from greater coordination of the data available from multiple sources and its interpretation as fishery performance indicators with flexible decision criteria, as part of their TAC setting process

Objectives

1. Facilitate a workshop to consolidate existing data, review analysis, interpretation and use as performance indicators in the TAC setting process, including development of a future monitoring plan.
2. Implement the short-term outcomes of the workshop, particularly related to development of the performance indicators, their use in updating population model scenarios of recovery, and combination in the TAC Setting process.

Final report

ISBN: 978-0-9870470-3-8
Authors: Peeters. H Worthington. D. Sainsbury. K. Halidoniotis. F. and Haddon. M.
Final Report • 2017-06-01 • 7.23 MB
2012-236-DLD.pdf

Summary

Management Strategy Evaluation (MSE) methods are used to examine the performance of prospective Harvest Control Rules for calculating the Total Allowable Catch (TAC) for the Western Zone (WZ) Abalone Fishery. Of particular importance is recovery of the stock following the combined effects of previous fishing and Abalone Viral Ganglioneuritis (AVG) mortality in 2006/7.

Measuring the economic value of recreational fishing at a national level

Project number: 2012-214
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $65,000.00
Principal Investigator: Ewan A. Colquhoun
Organisation: Ridge Partners
Project start/end date: 17 May 2012 - 29 Nov 2012
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Recreational fisheries have no reliable and acceptable methodology or mechanisms to measure their economic value (direct and indirect) to Australians.
More broadly, the sector has no clear understanding of end-user requirements for its economic data, and the most appropriate means of obtaining the required data.
The impacts of this problem are direct, substantial, local and national. Measurement enables monitoring of performance, which enables management of the resource to consistently achieve best outcomes. Lack of measurement means the sector cannot:
1. quantify the operational or economic size of the national fishery on a reliable and repeatable basis, and therefore can not measure or manage economic performance changes over time
2. demonstrate with acceptable accuracy the economic contribution to regional and national economies, at any time,
3. justify and motivate investment by communities, investors and agencies in recreational fishing,
4. clearly and unambiguously demonstrate that it is a relevant sector or contributor to regional and national economies.

The RFAC's 2011 Strategy identifies at least 2 goals (as follows) that demand some type of economic measure to demontrate that they have been achieved.
- Recreational fishing is acknowledged as an important activity that contributes to the health and well-being of Australian society.
- Recreational fishers have access to a fair and reasonable share of Australia’s fish resources.

Objectives

1. Identify end-users of Recreational Fishing data, their economic data needs, and appropriate data collection methods
2. Identify and short-list appropriate economic indicators and the preferred "GVP Equivalent" cross-jurisdictional approach
3. Establish a project Steering Group to work with the consultant, raise stakeholder awareness, and carry the project forward
4. Estimate and document the initial "GVP Equivalent" for the Recreational Fishing Sector by key jurisdiction and for the nation
5. Establish an Action Plan (resources, responsibilities, timing, etc) for measuring the economic contribution of the Recreational Fishing Sector or a repeatable annual basis
6. Establish a GVP Equivalent value of Recreational and Indigenous Fisheries as a permanent component of DAFF's determination of the Australian Fishing Industry
View Filter

Species

Organisation