4,571 results

An industry based mark recapture program to provide stock assessment inputs for the Western Rock Lobster Fishery following introduction of quota management

Project number: 2014-023
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $330,222.10
Principal Investigator: Jason How
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 18 May 2014 - 29 Jun 2017
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The recent change to quota management for the Western Rock Lobster fishery has resulted in significant changes in fishing behaviour which has affected the ability to use the long standing empirical catch rate indices that have been a major component of the assessment of lobster stocks (e.g. catch rates of legal, undersize and breeding lobsters). A recent FRDC funded study (2009/019) examined the possibility of using alternative data sources unbiased by effort to monitor biomass levels and exploitation rates using change-in-ratio techniques. The project concluded that:
1. The current data sources available to the fishery had too many unknowns including size and sex specific timing of growth and movement to enable the assessment of exploitation rates using these techniques.
2. A robust tag-recapture study using multiple release periods across different fishing seasons could generate independent assessments of legal biomass and exploitation rates providing an additional baseline level to improve the interpretation of post quota catch rate indices.
A comprehensive tag-recapture study would also provide increased resolution of the movement dynamics of lobsters, especially the rate of migration between management zones. Such information is considered vital by industry in their discussions of the potential benefits of voluntarily reducing quotas to generate increased localised catch rates.

Objectives

1. Determine spatially specific exploitation rates and legal biomass levels
2. Increase precision of estimates for movement rates between management zones
3. Improve understanding of the variability of growth throughout the range of the fishery

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-921258-76-3 (Print); 978-1-921258-77-0 (Online)
Author: Simon de Lestang
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 
Final Report • 2020-08-01 • 5.40 MB
2014-023-DLD.pdf

Summary

The West Coast Lobster Managed Fishery (WCRLMF) moved from input to output controls in 2010. This change directly affected the relativity of a number of fisherybased data sources, making assessment of the fishery more problematic. A novel examination of the stock dynamics was required to help ensure the stock assessment and associated management outcomes for this valuable resource were maintained. This study derived estimates of current biomass levels and harvest rates throughout the WCRLMF based on the release (over 40,000) of tagged Western Rock Lobsters (Panulirus cygnus) and the recapture of tagged lobsters, using a multi-stage modelling process. Components of this study, such as tag loss and reporting rates, were initially independently examined, before a generalised “Brownie” tag-recapture (BTR) model was implemented that provided an assessment on a fishery-wide basis. Finally a novel purpose-built individual-based model (IBM) was developed that was capable of producing estimates of biomass and harvest rates on finer spatial and temporal scale, as well as providing estimates of migration and growth. 

Application of tracking technologies to understand space-time explicit patterns of movement, residency and habitat use of pelagic sharks in Spencer Gulf: resolving overlaps with key community activities and marine industries

Project number: 2014-020
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $382,063.00
Principal Investigator: Paul J. Rogers
Organisation: SARDI Food Safety and Innovation
Project start/end date: 31 May 2014 - 31 Jul 2016
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Following many expressions of public concern regarding the potential for finfish/tuna aquaculture to attract sharks to coastal areas, at both regional development and individual site applications, PIRSA Fisheries and Aquaculture identified the need for an understanding of the factors that may explain associations between sharks and finfish/tuna aquaculture activities. This view was reinforced at meetings of the AAC (including a presentation from the PI on 22 Feb 2013), who are a legislated body under the Aquaculture Act 2001, advising the State Minister for Agriculture, Food and Fisheries on matters relating to aquaculture development. As a consequence, this project was listed as a priority area for investment by the SAFRAB.

A previous FRDC funded workshop (2002/040) identified a need to understand factors that may explain interactions between pelagic sharks and aquaculture activities. Some of the findings highlighted during this workshop are now considered to be outdated. For example, anecdotal accounts from finfish farmers and commercial fishers suggest that white sharks sightings have increased in the past decade in Spencer Gulf and this may have implications for the frequency of interactions with the fishing and aquaculture industry. The provision of data to further inform the public’s current perception of the aquaculture industry represents a key priority in South Australia’s Fisheries and Aquaculture R&D Strategy. During the development of this project the need for this research was discussed with key industry representatives.
This proposal addresses key objectives of the Draft White Shark Recovery Plan, 2010 (2c, 7a, 9a and 9b).

Objectives

1. Determine if activities associated with finfish aquaculture correlate with spatial and temporal residency and migration patterns of pelagic sharks.
2. Assess and compare patterns of residency of pelagic sharks in ‘natural’ foraging areas, and any overlaps with community activities.
3. Develop a Code of Practice for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture cages.

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-876007-09-6
Author: Dr Paul Rogers
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Final Report • 2018-09-01 • 5.12 MB
2014-020-DLD.pdf

Summary

The report focuses on the movement dynamics of two pelagic sharks, the White Shark (Carcharadon carcharias) and Bronze Whaler (Carcharinhus brachyurus), in South Australia. Specific aims were to: (1) determine if aquaculture activities correlated with patterns on fidelity and migration; and (2) assess and compare the use of natural foraging areas and areas used during human marine activities. Additional objectives included the development of: industry guidelines for removal and release of pelagic sharks from finfish aquaculture pontoons, and surveys to collect baseline information on perceptions of shark associations with aquaculture and other marine activities. 
Key outcomes of the project include provision of advice to marine policy-makers regarding overlaps between sharks, marine industries and areas used during community activities (including marine parks). This project addressed important research and management questions that existed for over a decade. 
Industry
PROJECT NUMBER • 2016-173
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Trade Mission: Creating a niche market for the supply of NSW Wild Caught mixed finfish to China through the GFresh B to B E-commerce platform

The Fisheries Research & Development Corporation (FRDC), the Sydney Fish Market and the Australia– China Agricultural Cooperation Agreement (ACACA) program agreed to fund the Professional Fishermen’s Association (PFA) proposed trade mission to China to explore the concept...
ORGANISATION:
Professional Fishers Association (PFA)
Industry
PROJECT NUMBER • 2013-746
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Seafood CRC: optimising the size and quality of sardines through real-time harvest monitoring

In order to improve the commercial profitability and sustainability of the South Australian Sardine Fishery (SASF) there was a need to establish improved monitoring and harvest management practices based on an understanding of Sardine habitat preferences. In this project, the South Australian...
ORGANISATION:
SARDI Food Safety and Innovation
SPECIES

Shark Futures: Sustainable management of the NSW whaler shark fishery

Project number: 2010-062
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $659,422.00
Principal Investigator: Vic M. Peddemors
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (NSW)
Project start/end date: 1 Jan 2012 - 10 Jul 2013
Contact:
FRDC

Need

World-wide, shark fisheries are reputedly unsustainable. The NPOA Sharks and IUCN list over-fishing as a major threat to Australian shark populations. In NSW, the OTLF catches most sharks. Both the FMS and EIS recognise this component as requiring urgent research due to the perceived high risk to targeted whaler sharks resulting from their known low fecundity and resultant susceptibility to over-fishing.

The OTLMAC and NSW SIAC reiterated concern following the rapid expansion of the large shark fishery during the mid-2000s. The impact of this expansion on the so-called ‘historical shark fishers’ was queried.
Recently, an independent review by CSIRO on behalf of DEWHA highlighted the lack of knowledge to effectively manage this fishery. Subsequently, a new overtly precautionary TAC was determined. This reduced TAC has the potential to negatively affect regional socio-economics. Data enabling a viable and sustainable shark fin fishery, while supporting the conditions for EPBC Act WTOs, are urgently required.

Significant investment by I&I NSW is providing data on shark species composition, their biology, fishing gear details, and spatio-temporal catch information. Although these data will substantially contribute to enabling suitable management protocols, I&I NSW fisheries managers have called for more information on:
(1) stock structure and effective population size to enable sustainable TACs to be set; (2) methods to reduce unwanted catch thereby minimizing environmental impact; (3) movements of target species to enable equitable State-wide access to the resource for fishers while providing temporal-spatial management options to improve risk-management of this fishery.

Considering the OTLF catch levels and historical collapse of other fisheries internationally targeting dusky and sandbar sharks, I&I NSW fisheries managers have requested particular focus on these two whaler shark species. This proposal aims to address the management needs through innovative new techniques utilizing linkages with several laboratories, national research programs and management agencies.

Objectives

1. Genetically resolve the effective population size of dusky and sandbar sharks targeted in the OTLF
2. Determine the short-term and distance movements of sandbar and dusky sharks to assist in the development of potential spatial management options like time-area (spatio-temporal) closures
3. Develop a fishing technique that will decrease mortality of unwanted species, particularly threatened and protected species, to minimize environmental impact of the fishery
4. Assess the effectiveness of the I&I NSW shark field ID-guide through ground-truthing on-board shark identification between fishers and observers, plus via genetic testing
5. Evaluate assessment methods and management indicators for the main shark species that may provide a model for future national and/or international data-poor shark fisheries
6. Apply assessment methods and management indicators for data-poor species that may provide a model for future national and/or international data-poor shark fisheries.
7. Provide scientific data-based advice for management to ensure the future sustainability of shark populations.

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-76058-395-8
Author: Victor Peddemors; Will Macbeth; Damian Collins; Andrew Goulstone; Matthew Ives; Jennifer Ovenden; Paul Butcher
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.
Final Report • 2021-04-30 • 3.50 MB
2010-062-DLD.pdf

Summary

New South Wales Department of Primary Industries (NSW DPI) presents new information exploring the shark catch of the NSW Ocean Trap & Line Fishery and developing methods to ensure an accurately reported, sustainable and profitable fishery for large sharks is maintained.
 
A combination of novel genetic techniques, extensive field work, and numerical modelling was undertaken during this FRDC Shark Futures project.
 
This allowed development of an innovative way to bring together genetic and demographic data for estimating population size and modelling sustainable catch levels for target species. Identification of shark species has historically been problematic with many species lumped into similar groups in historical catch logbooks. The new NSW catch logbooks differentiate between shark species caught in commercial fisheries and a corresponding shark identification guide provided to fishers. We assess the effectiveness of this guidebook in providing accurate catch reporting and determine the minimum data required to be collected to enable fisheries managers and compliance officers to effectively regulate a large shark fishery. As management options have often included a trip limit of total allowable catch, we investigated the fate of sharks caught on demersal longlines and model factors affecting their post-release survivorship. This is particularly pertinent for non-selective fishing gear such as demersal longlines which hook species of conservation value and other bycatch as part of their normal fishing operations. Finally, we also assess the levels of metals and metalloids in shark product sold from this fishery to determine whether there could be any negative health implications for human consumers. Excessive levels of mercury and arsenic were detected and suggestions subsequently made on how to ensure product from NSW large shark fisheries are kept within the standards of Food Standards Australia New Zealand.

Developing triple bottom line harvest strategies that include all environmental aspects for multi-sector fisheries

Project number: 2015-013
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $304,607.83
Principal Investigator: Natalie A. Dowling
Organisation: CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Hobart
Project start/end date: 14 Apr 2016 - 14 Oct 2018
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The triple-bottom-line (TBL) of environmental/ecological, economic and social management objectives is important for stock sustainability, supporting environment health, resource access, certainty, export approvals and public confidence. However, it has yet to be operationalised within a harvest strategy context.

A harvest strategy (HS) framework specifies pre-determined management actions in a fishery to achieve management objectives via monitoring, assessment and decision rules. As opposed to a broader management strategy or procedure, HSs focus on controlling exploitation rates for relevant species.

To address the TBL requires

a) understanding the impact of environmental (bycatch, habitat, broader), economic and social aspects on a fishery,
b) elicitation of objectives and an understanding of the trade-offs between these,
d) assessment methods that may be applied within a HS.

The National HS Guidelines (FRDC 2010/061) state the importance of establishing operational TBL objectives. The National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development stipulates that these objectives must be considered simultaneously, with none predominating. Queensland fishery management in the Great Barrier Reef Region aims to simultaneously achieve the objectives of the Fisheries Act (Qld) and the GBRMP Act (that permits ecologically sustainable use provided it is consistent with the main object of long-term environmental protection). Thus, addressing the TBL in a HS context is paramount for Queensland GBR fisheries.

The National HS Guidelines recommended the development of case studies to test their practical application, with priority assigned to multi-sector (e.g. commercial and recreational) fisheries that are directly confronted with TBL objectives (noting their mixed data quality and quantity). FRDC 2010/040 developed and tested social objectives for fisheries management but emphasised the outstanding need to integrate social objectives/indicators within HS frameworks.

Queensland multi-sector GBR fisheries provide an ideal starting point to develop and recommend TBL HSs, and one that is timely given the current review of Queensland fisheries management.

Objectives

1. To undertake a review of (existing work around) multi-objective management systems and associated assessment approaches (Phase 1)
2. To compile an inventory (incorporating existing work, and particularly that of 2013/204) of current environmental, economic and social objectives and consider how to translate such conceptual management objectives to operational objectives for multi-sector fisheries. (Phase 1)
3. To develop a theoretical framework (incorporating existing) methods and approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between, and/or priorities for, environmental, economic and social objectives (Phase 1)
4. KEY OBJECTIVE: to develop a general Methodology for harvest strategy development against the triple-bottom-line for multi-sector fisheries (Phase 1)
5. To finalise the choice of Queensland state-based multi-sector case study fishery (Phase 1)
6. KEY OBJECTIVE: to develop and recommend (but NOT to formally implement and/or operationalize) a triple bottom line harvest strategy framework for a Queensland multi-sector case study fishery (Phase 2)

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-925994-15-5
Authors: Natalie Dowling Catherine Dichmont Sean Pascoe Toni Cannard George Leigh Rachel Pears Tom Roberts Sian Breen
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Final Report • 2020-10-16 • 5.57 MB
2015-013-DLD.pdf

Summary

Based on the results of a comprehensive literature review and the collective expertise of the project team, we developed two alternative approaches with which to evaluate trade-offs between triple bottom line objectives and stakeholder preferences: a semi-quantitative multi-criteria decision analysis framework, and a quantitative simulation model approach.
Environment
PROJECT NUMBER • 2018-212
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Establishing an industry recovery strategy for the Area 3 zone of the Western Australian Abalone Managed Fishery

The Southern Seafood Producers (Western Australia) Association in conjunction with the Abalone Industry Association of Western Australia hosted a two-day workshop (the workshop) at the Swan Yacht Club in East Fremantle on the 12th and 13th of June 2019. The aim of the workshop was to...
ORGANISATION:
Southern Seafood Producers (WA) Association

Mud cockle (Katelysia spp.) stock enhancement/restoration: practical implementation and policy evaluation

Project number: 2014-028
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $250,432.00
Principal Investigator: Xiaoxu Li
Organisation: SARDI Food Safety and Innovation
Project start/end date: 16 Jul 2014 - 29 Jun 2017
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

Mud cockles have been an important resource to the seafood industry, recreational fishers and ecosystem of SA. These species are subject to episodic recruitment that is strongly influenced by the environment. For example, the combination of fishing and adverse environmental conditions at the Section Bank has resulted in PIRSA closing this area to fishing from 2011. As these difficulties could arise in any mud cockle fishery, e.g. a severe mud cockle mortality event occurred during December 2013 in Streaky Bay, there is a strong need to develop the capacity to recover the depleted stocks through reseeding. Section Bank is an ideal location for a case study because it has been closed to commercial and recreational fishing for more than three years.

While marine stock enhancement/restoration programs are variable in success, the approach seems well suited to cockle species, which in many countries are farmed by planting spat into the sandy substrate and harvesting them when they have reached market size. Stock enhancement/restoration also continues to advance with improved policies (e.g. PIRSA F&A Draft Policy for the Release of Aquatic Resources) and the “responsible approach” advocated by Lorenzen et al (2010) and Hart et al (2013) where methodologies are used to ensure that the genetic heterogeneity of natural populations is maintained and that hatchery stock is disease free before release.

Benefit cost analyses have shown very encouraging potential for stock enhancement in pipi and greenlip abalone. For example, a benefit cost ratio of 3.34:1 and a two year investment return were anticipated for pipi reseeding in NSW (Phelps et al 2008). Similar or greater levels of benefit can be predicted for mud cockle stock enhancement in SA by substituting the information for pipi with that for K. rhytiphora based on our findings in FRDC 2009/208 project.

Objectives

1. Develop optimal methodologies for transporting and planting hatchery produced mud cockle, K. scalarina, for stock enhancement/restoration at Section Bank.
2. Evaluate post-stocking performance of two hatchery produced mud cockle, K. scalarina and K. rhytiphora, at Section Bank.
3. Develop a monitoring program that can be incorporated within the existing industry mud cockle stock assessment program to determine the long-term success of stock enhancement/restoration.
4. Optimise mud cockle stock enhancement/restoration strategies for Section Bank through benefit cost evaluation of different options using the model developed in FRDC project 2008/071.
5. Transfer knowledge gained from this project to Government fisheries and aquaculture managers and policy makers, and cockle fishers in SA.

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-876007-38-6
Authors: Miller-Ezzy P.A. Stone D.A.J. and Li X.
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 
Final Report • 2021-08-01 • 1.59 MB
2014-028-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was conducted to restore the Mud Cockle population in the Section Bank of Port River, South Australia, which had drastically decreased due to commercial fishing. Mud Cockles are important not only for commercial purposes but also for stabilizing sediment and reducing turbidity in the environment. The study developed procedures for transporting and planting hatchery-produced Mud Cockle seed into the field to optimize growth and survival. Pilot studies were undertaken to assess transportation and tagging procedures. Five trials were conducted at two different sites with different population sizes with the aims of testing planted Mud Cockle survival and growth across different seasons, sites, stocking densities, stocking size classes and predator protective methods. The study found that seasonal water temperature has the strongest influence on the apparent survival and growth of the re-seeded Mud Cockle spat. The results from the pilot studies indicated that Pacific Oyster spat transportation methods were suitable for Mud Cockle spat and painting one valve of the Mud Cockles with Rosario Pink paint was the most effective method for marking experimental spat. 
 

Assessment of the impacts of seal populations on the seafood industry in South Australia

Project number: 2013-011
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $380,000.00
Principal Investigator: Simon D. Goldsworthy
Organisation: SARDI Food Safety and Innovation
Project start/end date: 30 Jun 2013 - 31 May 2016
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The last 25 years have seen a 3.5 fold increase in the population size of New Zealand fur seals (NZFS) in SA, which now number over 85,000 individuals. This recovery may continue for a further 15-30 years, and the level at which populations may stabilise is unknown. New haul-out sites and breeding colonies are establishing across the State, some in close proximity to finfish aquaculture, and major commercial and recreational fishing areas. In addition, an Australian fur seal population has recently established in SA and has more than doubled in the last five years. There is also growing concern from the seafood and ecotourism (little penguins, giant cuttlefish) industries and the community that fur seals are overabundant and that their populations and impacts need to be managed. As a consequence of this broad industry and public concern, this project was listed as one of the priority areas for investment by the SAFRAB.

Most of the seals that interact with fisheries, aquaculture and ecotourism are juvenile and sub-adult males that restrict their feeding the shelf waters; however the diet and foraging behaviour of this part of the population is poorly understood. Little is also understood about the potential competitive interactions between the three species of seals that may be limiting the recovery of the threatened Australian sea lion. The project aims to investigate the diets and foraging distributions of seals in SA’s gulf and shelf waters to assess the importance of commercial fish and finfish aquaculture species in their diet. Trophic modelling will be used to assess the impact of consumption on current and future seafood production, and industry questionnaires and consultation will be used to assess the economic impact and the degree and nature of interactions between seals and finfish aquaculture, fisheries and marine ecotourism industries.

Objectives

1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-876007-16-4
Author: Simon Goldsworthy
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.
Final Report • 2019-06-20 • 11.75 MB
2013-011-DLD.pdf

Summary

This report provides the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of seals on the seafood industry in South Australia, where management of both the real and perceived impacts of seals has become a very complex socio-ecological economic issue. 
The objectives of the project where to:
1. Determine the importance of commercial and recreational fish and fin-fish aquaculture species in diets of seals
2. Determine the spatial distribution of foraging and consumption effort of fur seals relative to important fin-fish aquaculture and commercial and recreational fishing areas
3. Estimate the impacts of consumption by seals, and the implications of increasing populations on the future biomass of commercially and recreationally important marine taxa on seafood and marine ecotourism industries
4. Estimate the costs to the fin-fish aquaculture industry from stock losses, deterrent methods and maintenance requirements associated with seal interactions
5. Assess perceptions of the economic impacts of operational and trophic interactions with seals on seafood and on other species such as little penguin, giant cuttlefish and the potential ecological displacement of Australian sea lions from increasing fur seal populations
The social perception surveys confirmed that concerns about the impacts of recovering populations of seals on seafood industries, marine communities and coastal ecosystems of South Australia have clearly intensified in recent years - thus becoming a very complex socio-ecological economic issues.

Sturgeon aquaculture in Australia: feasibility study

Project number: 2016-210
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $140,000.00
Principal Investigator: Marty R. Deveney
Organisation: SARDI Food Safety and Innovation
Project start/end date: 30 Jun 2016 - 29 Jun 2019
Contact:
FRDC
SPECIES

Need

Australian aquaculture industries are expanding, and the South Australian aquaculture industry aims to double production by 2020. Increased aquaculture production will rely on new species and products and intensification of existing industries. Australia has high production costs and new products need to be high value to remain competitive.

The Siberian sturgeon (Acipenser baeri) and beluga (Huso huso), which produce caviar and meat were added to the live import list for commercial aquaculture in 2015. These species are long lived and late maturing presenting an extended period between introduction and production of caviar. There is a consequent need to assess the commercial potential of sturgeon aquaculture in Australia, to drive processes to obtain regulatory consent and to establish links to facilitate technology transfer and RD&E.

This project will assess the feasibility of sturgeon aquaculture in Australia, including identification of the most appropriate and expedient way to bring sturgeon to Australia, identify appropriate sources for stock, develop standards for import and holding of stock, and link Australia to a network of world sturgeon farming knowledge.

This project will utilise expertise from PIRSA Fisheries and Aquaculture, SARDI Aquatic Sciences, the Australian aquaculture industry and relevant international experts to meet information requirements for regulatory approvals, to identify and develop methods to manage risk and provide a sound basis for industry development.

Objectives

1. Determine requirements for importing sturgeons into Australia
2. Develop and maintain networks to establish and maintain sturgeon aquaculture in Australia
3. Develop desktop understanding of feasibility of sturgeon aquaculture in Australia
4. Provide information to facilitate import of sturgeons to Australia

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-876007-32-4
Author: Marty Deveney & Jade Davison
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

Final Report • 2020-11-01

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish of the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge. Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

 

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

 
The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

Final Report • 2020-11-01

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish of the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge. Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

 

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

 
The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

Final Report • 2020-11-01

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish of the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge. Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

 

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

 
The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

Final Report • 2020-11-01

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish of the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge. Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

 

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

 
The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

Final Report • 2020-11-01

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish of the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge. Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

 

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

 
The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.
Final Report • 2020-11-01 • 961.39 KB
2016-210-DLD.pdf

Summary

This project examined the feasibility of farming sturgeons in Australia. These large fish in the family Acipenseridae are the source of caviar, one of the world’s highest value luxury goods. Australian aquaculture has goals to expand and one way to achieve this is to farm high-value products that require technology and high quality environments in which Australia can deliver a competitive edge.  Sturgeons are not native to Australia and the project aimed to collate information to assess if sturgeon farming in Australia is biologically and technically feasible; and if so, to gather material that could support the import of sturgeons.

A major component of the project was ongoing dialogue with the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment (DAWE), the regulatory authority for importing biological commodities into Australia.  The information aimed to provide input to processes, including Biosecurity Risk Analysis, that are used by DAWE to inform development of import conditions.

Project staff engaged with local and overseas experts and industry and developed networks that will be useful if an industry develops.  Sources of stock were identified for eventual establishment of an Australian industry.

We assessed the business feasibility of an Australian sturgeon industry by developing a business case including a projected cost-profit model.  This assessment concluded that farming sturgeons in Australia is biologically and technically feasible and has a 10 year lifecycle to profit if developed as a mixed sturgeon-trout farm.  Caviar demand and sales are increasing but there are substantial threats to an Australian caviar industry.  There is extensive caviar production in China which is likely to continue to grow, and world caviar prices have fallen substantially since 2010, although wholesale prices in Australia have remained high and stable over the same period.

The project team was unable to develop and negotiate approaches to overcome the regulatory barriers to importing sturgeons.  Although clear pathways are identified, import consent remains a difficult goal.  Alternative arrangements were rejected as an approach by DAWE in August 2020.  For sturgeon import to Australia to occur, DAWE needs to commence and complete a Biosecurity Import Risk Assessment (BIRA), but DAWE lacks available resources to commence that assessment.  Substantial data have been collated by this project to contribute to a BIRA.  Continued effort from industry will be required if sturgeon import is going to occur, but it is also possible that the perceived benefits do not justify the work required.

View Filter

Species

Organisation