Assessment of the implications of target fishing on black jewfish (Protonibea diacanthus) aggregations in the Northern Territory

Project number: 2004-004
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $241,250.00
Principal Investigator: Michael Phelan
Organisation: Department of Agriculture and Fisheries (NT)
Project start/end date: 29 Apr 2005 - 20 Mar 2008
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The 1999-2003 Northern Territory Strategic R&D Plan in considering catch rates, current levels of exploitation and management requirements, ranked NT Coastal Line Fishery research as one of highest priority. The most recent revision of this plan further clarifies these concerns and clearly identifies that "Harvesting of fish and other aquatic resources can only be sustainable if the long-term rate of harvest does not exceed the long-term rate of replacement to the stock(s). Increasing catches and target fishing evident for black jewfish and high exploitation of spawning aggregations may render the stocks unsustainable. In view of the above, re-commencement of research on coastal fisheries is considered a high priority for the next 5 years" (NT Strategic Plan for R&D 2002-06). Worldwide experience in managing aggregating species indicates that they are extremely vulnerable to overfishing.

The Coastal Line Fishery (CLF) logbook data and anecdotal information from fishers provides evidence of target fishing on black jewfish aggregations in NT waters. Significant changes in the CLF catch composition have occurred over a short period and the increase in total catch can be directly attributed to the increased catch of black jewfish. Over the period 1990-2001 the percent contribution of black jewfish to the total catch has increased from 11% to 77%. Once a multi-species fishery the CLF is now primarily a black jewfish fishery with a reef fish bycatch. In 1999 the CLF black jewfish catch reached 58 tonnes increasing 93% in just twelve months to 101 tonnes in 2000. Catch per unit effort (CPUE) for the same period increased just 27%. Black jewfish catch continues to increase, reaching 136 tonnes in 2002 and 167 tonnes in 2003, while CPUE has remained stable.

Of great concern is that these changes in black jewfish catch have occurred while considerable latent effort exists in this fishery. In 2002 only 27 of the 58 (46%) CLF licences issued, actively fished and of these just seven were responsible for 80% of the total catch. Increasing returns to a small group of fishers has created much interest in this fishery with new vessels and fishers from other fisheries preparing to fish for jewfish. The potential for increased effort in this fishery is high.

The 1995 the NT recreational harvest of Black Jewfish was estimated at 232 tonnes (FISHCOUNT) approximately six times the 1995 commercial catch (32 tonnes). The 2000 National Recreational and Indigenous Fishing Survey indicates that the NT recreational catch of black jewfish has reduced by approximately 25% to around 140 tonnes in 2000 (Henry and Lyle 2003).

Anecdotal reports from both commercial and recreational fishers suggesting a decline in the average size of black jewfish in the NT. Re-commencement of on-board monitoring of the commercial fishery is a key component of this project as such data is considered critical in assessing the impact of fishing on these aggregations.

Analysis of commercial catch and effort data suggests that the commercial fleet is moving from one aggregation to another, as aggregations are depleted and the same pattern of a more localised nature is highly likely for the recreational fishery.

The Aquatic Resource Management Section of the NT Fisheries Group has an urgent need for information on the make up of black jewfish aggregations in the NT. Information such as: Why do the aggregations occur? Why do they occur at particular sites? What is the extent and timing of movements between aggregations? Where do the fish go when not in aggregations? This project will address these questions directly. It will also provide leads for broader and more complex questions such as: what proportion of the stock is vulnerable in aggregations; to what extent does protection of one site affect fish at other sites; how mobile might sites be etc.

The current paucity of information is a critical impediment to the ability of the Fisheries Group to provide adequate protection of the Northern Territory’s black jewfish stocks and associated fisheries.

Objectives

1. Identify key sites of black jewfish aggregations and monitor fishing activity at these sites
2. Determine the degree of movement between two known aggregation sites (This objective now refers to FRDC 2004-02)
3. Determine the temporal, spatial and biological nature of the aggregations (Note linkage to FRDC 2004-02)
4. Review and adjust management arrangements as appropriate

Final report

ISBN: 978-0-7245-4729-6
Author: Michael J. Phelan

Related research

Environment
Industry
Environment

Bringing economic analysis and stock assessment together in the NPF: a framework for a biological and economically sustainable fishery

Project number: 2004-022
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $495,501.00
Principal Investigator: Cathy M. Dichmont
Organisation: CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Hobart
Project start/end date: 30 Mar 2005 - 31 Aug 2008
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Management arrangements for the NPF tiger prawn fishery are currently chosen so that the spawning stock biomass should recover to the level at which Maximum Sustainable Yield, MSY, is achieved with more than 70% certainty by 2006. MSY is a management reference point that is based solely on biological considerations. From an economic point of view (one that seeks to maximize economic efficiency and fishery returns) this target is inappropriate. The current rebuilding strategy implies that the NORMAC may, over time, be able to reassess the present harsh management measures instituted in the NORMAC agreed effort reduction program in 2001. However, in recent years it has become clear that the fishery is unable to wait for prawn recovery without addressing economic efficiency. NORMAC has identified an urgent need for a further fishery restructure (without compromising biological recovery) so as to maintain economic sustainability and profitability.

An immediate need is for this project to quantify the size of the fleet and length of the season given the biology of ALL the prawn resources. At present it is only broadly possible to answer this question if prawns other than tiger prawns and within year dynamics are ignored (which is unacceptable).

Additionally, this prawn fishery still needs to keep track of its fishing impacts. The main method in the past, with much success, has been through bycatch reduction by TEDs and BRDs. It is now possible, also to include fishing impacts in the modelling mechanisms to allow broader and better informed decision making.

Management advice provided by the NPF Assessment Group needs to take account of the impacts on the stock, economic efficiency and the ecosystem. Input controls are such that several different combinations of fleet size, gear size and season length can produce the same biological outcome but these options would not be equally economically efficient. It is not only overall effort levels that matter for economic efficiency but the manner in which vessels combine inputs in harvest that matters for economic efficiency. This decision over input combinations is sensitive to management decisions and as yet there is no clear economic evaluation of the fishery efficiency under current management practices in a combined biological and economic study.

Limit and target reference points, such as the MSY, in this fishery have only been investigated from the point of view of tiger prawn sustainability. It has been shown in other parts of the world that choosing management arrangements so that fishing effort corresponds to MSY does not necessarily lead to the highest profits and, in fact, lower effort levels generally lead to larger profits and more efficient outcomes. Furthermore, fishing below MSY may also benefit bycatch and byproduct species.

There is therefore a need that future stock assessment undertakes a holistic management view of this prawn fishery. Reference points and management advice should be aimed towards maximising economic return, while ensuring long term target species sustainability and minimising the impact of this fishery on other species wherever possible.

This can only be achieved by:
a) joining the databases held separately by AFMA, CSIRO and ABARE/ANU, and
b) combining the Management Strategy Evaluation frameworks produced by CSIRO on tiger prawns (FRDC 2001/002), ANU/ABARE on economic efficiency (FRRF) and CSIRO investigating effects of trawling on the seabed (FRDC 2002/102).

Objectives

1. Construct a comprehensive and consistent combined data base for the NPF, by integrating the existing data held by CSIRO and ABARE data.
2. Develop an analysis technique that integrates stock assessment within an economic framework by combining features of the methods developed by ABARE/ANU and CSIRO to enable evaluation of economic efficiency and fishery returns.
3. Develop a basic ecosystem model that synthesises present knowledge about the NPF ecosystem that can be driven at spatial and temporal scales appropriate to stock assessment.
4. Extend the current Management Strategy Evaluation framework to include economic outputs and outputs related to the impact of the fishery on the ecosystem.
5. Evaluate alternative management decision rules for the NPF in terms of their impacts on stock sustainability, economic efficiency, economic returns and ecosystem impacts.

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-921424-13-7
Author: Catherine Dichmont