The effects of western rock lobster fishing on the deepwater ecosystems off the west coast of Western Australia

Project number: 2004-049
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $1,783,713.00
Principal Investigator: Lynda Bellchambers
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 14 Aug 2004 - 30 Jul 2008
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The Scientific Reference Group (SRG), including Drs Alistar Robertson, Simon Thrush, Andrew Heyward, John Keesing, Colin Buxton, Chris Simpson and Jim Penn, was formed as an independent body to provide advice on research directions, to examine the effects of western rock lobster fishing on the ecosystem. The SRG identified that there is a major gap in the understanding of the interactions between the rock lobster fishery and the ecosystem in deep water. Although significant data is available on the shallow (40 m) water ecology of lobsters and the fishing impact there is gap in the knowledge of the deep-water ecology of lobster. They recognised that the major change in abundance and size structure of the western rock lobster population would have occurred in deep water (40-100 m), and concluded this was a priority area of research. There is a need to collect basic ecological information to determine if changes in lobster density and size structure,due to fishing has caused significant changes in habitat structure and benthic community composition in deep water. This will provide information on the level of ecosystem impact of removing lobsters from deep-water habitats to improve the assessment of risk to the ecosystem to ensure that the western rock lobster fishery maintains MSC certification and complies with DEH requirements for export permits. However, the SRG recognised that research needs to occur in a structured manner and have highlighted the need for research proposals which sit within the strategic framework which they have devised. The SRG recognises that the provision of a strategic framework and related scientific research will ultimately allow management of deep-water stocks in a more sophisticated ecosystem-based manner.

Objectives

1. To identify gradients in the density/size distribution of western rock lobster to enable selection of representative areas.
2. To assess the catchability of western rock lobster and its relationship with population abundance and size structure
3. To identify the relationship between the deep-water habitat and the density/size distribution of western rock lobster to enable a preliminary evaluation of the impact of lobster biomass removal in the deep-water

Final report

ISBN: 1-921258-76-4
Author: Lynda Bellchambers

Related research

Communities
Adoption
PROJECT NUMBER • 2022-063
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

WRL Communication, Education and Engagement Program

1. Strengthen industry members' engagement: Increase the full participation by internal stakeholders in Council activities, to best enable the Council to represent the industry to government and other stakeholders. This includes industry engagement and communication of WRL IPA activities and R&D...
ORGANISATION:
Western Rock Lobster Council Inc (WRLC)
Communities

Stock evaluation and recruitment measurement in the WA pearl oyster fishery

Project number: 1992-147
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $437,056.10
Principal Investigator: Lindsay Joll
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) WA
Project start/end date: 7 Mar 1993 - 2 Apr 1997
Contact:
FRDC

Objectives

1. To develop techniques for the assessment of pearl diver efficiency and selectivity in taking pearl oysters.
2. To consider the impact of fishing on the reproductive potential of wild stock pearl oysters.
3. To develop a database on recruitment to commercially fished grounds.
4. To examine geographic variability in pearl oyster growth rates and age at recruitment to the fishery
5. To examine the degree of genetic difference between populations of Pinctada albina
6. To examine the disease status of Broome and Shark Bay stocks of P. albina

Using information for 'data-rich' species to inform assessments of 'data-poor' species through Bayesian stock assessment methods

Project number: 2002-094
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $176,237.00
Principal Investigator: David Smith
Organisation: Agriculture Victoria
Project start/end date: 29 Sep 2002 - 30 Nov 2005
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Over 300 species are caught in the SEF, of which around 100 have commercial value. Twenty five species comprise around 90% of the landed catch. Each year, however, quotas are set for only around 17 species. There are 10 of these species for which there is (or has been) some formal stock assessment (that may not occur every year). For all of the remaining quota species and some of the more important non-quota species, no formal assessment is undertaken and the only assessment that can be made is based on investigation of trends in catch and effort and size distribution and anecdotal input from scientists and industry. There is simply not enough resources to undertake formal stock assessments for the wide range of commercial species landed in the SEF. Yet, each of these species is an important component of the catch of fishers. If the fishery is to continue to operate in its current form and meet the strategic assessments required under the EPBC Act, some form of formal assessment is required.

A recently completed ARF project (Production parameters from the fisheries literature for SEF-like species - Project no R99/0308) demonstrated the utility of using information for "similar" species when conducting assessments for SEF species. Using key parameters such as the virgin biomass, the rate of natural mortality, and the “steepness” of the stock-relationship relationship, a simple formula was developed for identifying “similar” stocks / species and an algorithm was developed for constructing prior probability distributions for these parameters. The resultant distributions can be used in Bayesian stock assessments and as the basis for sensitivity tests when applying other methods of stock assessments. The current project will refine the prior distributions for the production parameters and develop and test methods of stock assessment that use the results of assessments for well-studied species in a formal manner to inform assessments of ‘data-poor’ species. If successful, the methods developed would lead to significant benefits not only for the assessment and management of "data poor" SEF low priority, by-product and by-catch species, but also for a range of new and developing fisheries in Australia.

Objectives

1. Expand the database of production parameters for SEF-like species
2. Develop prior probability distributions for steepness and the coefficient of variation about the stock-recruitment relationship using Bayesian meta-analysis
3. Develop a Bayesian framework within which the results for data-rich species can 'inform' assessments for data-poor species.
4. Apply the framework to three case-studies to determine the robustness of the framework.
5. Test the framework by means on Monte Carlo simulation

Final report

Southern bluefin tuna research review

Project number: 2002-103
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $22,133.84
Principal Investigator: Mary Lack
Organisation: Shellack Pty Ltd
Project start/end date: 13 Dec 2002 - 30 Jun 2004
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The environment in which the SBT fishery operates both domestically and internationally has changed in recent years. The domestic fishery, along with other Commonwealth managed fisheries, has come under greater scrutiny as a result of the implementation of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 and an increased focus on ecosystem-wide impacts of fishing as opposed to a concentration on management of only target species.
Internationally, efforts to ensure that the global catch of SBT is managed under the CCSBT have seen Korea recently join the Commission and Taiwan agree to join the Commission. The Commission has been unable to agree on a TAC and national allocations amongst its members since 1997. This results largely from disagreement about the chances of stock recovery at current catch levels. To address this issue the Commission agreed in November 2000 on a framework for a Scientific Research Program (SRP) and the appointment of an advisory panel of eminent international fisheries scientists to oversee the program. In May 2002 the Australian Government announced funding for the SRP of $3m over the period 2002/03 to 2003/04.
The exclusion of Japanese vessels from the AFZ since 1997 has seen a dramatic reduction in the availability of research funding (in 1995/96 the access fees provided $680,000 for research).
Given these changes research funding and management/policy agencies are keen to ensure that:
- research is well targeted to the current and future needs of the fishery;
- the structures in place for determining research strategies, research projects and priorities and for delivering research are the most appropriate and effective;
- the research funded is that which delivers the highest returns to increasingly scarce research funds;
- research is driven by management needs; and
- Australia has the capacity to deliver and to articulate research results.

Objectives

1. Analyse outcomes/expected outcomes of past, ongoing and current SBT research projects.
2. Identify gaps in current research
3. Ensure the processes for developing, prioritising, selecting and funding SBT research projects are effective and appropriate

Final report