Variation in banana prawn catches at Weipa: a comprehensive regional study

Project number: 2004-024
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $333,005.00
Principal Investigator: Peter Rothlisberg
Organisation: CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Hobart
Project start/end date: 29 Jan 2004 - 29 May 2007
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Research in the Northern Prawn Fishery has focussed on aspects of the fishery, biology and environment of the prawns and bycatch species. Recent studies have also started to look at the broader effects of fishing in the NPF. The NPF is moving to managing the fishery in an ecosystem context i.e. with a better understanding of the factors that affect prawn and non-target species populations, other than fishing. To achieve this goal, research, management and industry need to develop broader, and more integrated approaches to understanding different factors that are likely to affect the fishery. The development of these approaches parallel the NPF’s goal of moving to an Environmental Management System. The research in this proposal will build a framework for developing an understanding of variation in banana prawn stocks in the Weipa region, in an ecosystem context, and develop more integrated approaches for research and management strategy evaluation in the NPF. It will provide a prototype approach and models for potential application to the broader NPF and other prawn fisheries in northern Australia.

The Weipa region is a high priority area as catches have been only one tenth of the long-term average catch for 4 consecutive years, even though other regions have had extremely high catches during this time. These low catches in the Weipa region can not be explained by low rainfall alone. The decline in catch from Weipa has resulted in a decline in exported banana prawns in the region from a value of about $12 million a year less than $1.2 million each year.

The research in this proposal bridges two high priority research areas identified by NORMAC in its 2003 research priorities: 1. Assessment of the status of the fishery including management strategies for the fishery; and 2. Improved knowledge of environmental factors of importance to the fishery. It also addresses a priority research area identified by the NPFAG at its May 2003 meeting.

Objectives

1. Examination of the possible reasons (e.g. fishing, biological, environmental) for the currently low banana prawn catches in the Weipa region
2. Integration of data, development of a framework and models to test hypotheses on the reasons for low banana prawn catches i.e. that they are due to: (a) historical high levels of fishing
(b) a change in the trophodynamics (e.g. predator-prey balance) in the region
and/or (c) a change in the environment in the region – either offshore, estuaries, and/or the river systems that flow into the estuary
3. Define the scope and utility of decision support systems to enhance management and operational decisions on prawn fishing
4. Assessment of the relevance of the approach to other regions of the Northern Prawn Fishery and other prawn fisheries

Final report

Author: Peter Rothlisberg
Final Report • 2007-11-20 • 1.97 MB
2004-024-DLD.pdf

Summary

Since about the year 2000 there have been very low catches in the Weipa Region of the Northern Prawn Fishery (NPF); these low catches were different to other areas of the NPF where they continued to fluctuate around long-term means and continued to fall within predicted levels. Industry and managers were concerned about these anomalous catch levels and debated whether or not the very low catches were a result of: overfishing; changes in the environment; changes in fishing practices; or the result of recent management changes. This project was meant to explore these possible hypotheses and advise management of a course of action.

The project was an 18 month desktop study which examined historical catch and environmental data by a variety of means. Three workshops were attended by experts from CSIRO, QDPI, universities, fishers and managers. Several approaches were simultaneously undertaken by four Working Groups. In addition there were also studies on: reproductive dynamics; fleet dynamics; trophodynamics; and fishing effort analysis. A Decision Support Framework was established for systematically examining the hypotheses, thresholds of accepting or rejecting them, and suggested management actions determined.

Final Report • 2007-11-20 • 4.56 MB
2004-024 Appendices.pdf

Summary

Appendices to the final report 2004-024.

Related research

People
Adoption
Industry

Determining ecological effects of longline fishing in the Eastern Tuna and Billfish Fishery

Project number: 2004-063
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $562,357.40
Principal Investigator: Jock Young
Organisation: CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Hobart
Project start/end date: 14 Apr 2005 - 30 Nov 2008
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The ET&BF is presently dealing separately with a number of ecological issues. For example, impacts of longliners on shearwaters and turtles are current high profile problems. However, other issues such as depletion of swordfish, SBT bycatch, availability of tunas in relation to oceanographic features, bycatch of sharks and finning have all taken centre stage at different times in the short history of the domestic fishery. This approach is often reactionary, rather than strategic, and may not be the best use of research resources over the long-term. If the ET&BF is to move substantially toward ecosystem-based fishery management, as it is required to do under the EPBC act, rather than continue the individual species management approach, an ecosystem analysis providing ecosystem metrics must be developed. If, for example, ET&BF managers opt for time area closures as part of their management strategy to protect key species, developing these on a species-by-species basis has the potential to impact the whole fishery. To develop and evaluate time area closures that allow for minimizing risk of adverse impacts to the suite of key species, while allowing for optimal efficiency of fishing, understanding the associations, linkages and interactions between species is essential. This is the ecosystem approach. Developing an understanding of how ecosystem-associations relate to oceanographic features is also essential in open ocean systems where the dominant influence on distribution and local abundance is oceanography. The approach we are taking will provide the information needed to support an ecosystem-based management framework. Through the analyses we are proposing we will identify regional “hot spots”, detail their linkages and provide detailed scenarios as to how we think different management strategies and fishing practices will or will not impact pelagic food chains, ecologically related non-target species, competitors (e.g. sharks, marlins etc.) and their associated ecosystems. The need for ecosystem-based fishery management for the Western Pacific region has also been supported by PrepCon for the soon-to-be formed WCPFC (Working Paper 9, 2002).

Objectives

1. Identify the spatial extent and the temporal stability of the main ecosystems of the eastern tuna and billfish fishery based on their species composition and physical environment.
2. Define the trophic structure within these ecosystems with emphasis on the relationship between target, bycatch and threatened and protected species.
3. Develop an ecosystem model for the ETBF fishery incorporating data on the relative abundance of the species, trophic linkages and the physical environment from which the impacts of longline fishing on the ecosystem can be investigated and from which alternative harvest strategies can be evaluated.

Final report

ISBN: 9.78E+12
Author: Jock Young