Evaluation of methods to assess abalone abundance

Project number: 1993-100
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $166,101.00
Principal Investigator: Harry Gorfine
Organisation: Agriculture Victoria
Project start/end date: 14 Nov 1993 - 25 Mar 1999
Contact:
FRDC

Objectives

1. To compare methods of abundance estimation in determining the effects of stock depletion by pulse fishing a stunted backlip abalone population.

Final report

Author: Harry Gorfine
Final Report • 1996-07-29 • 1.30 MB
1993-100-DLD.pdf

Summary

The issue of how best to survey abalone populations to obtain estimates of abundance has been the subject of debate among fisheries biologists for many years.  In an attempt to resolve this issue we compared and evaluated abalone abundance estimated by the following methods: Transect survey, Timed-collection surveys, Mark-Recapture, Change-in-Ratio and Leslie (catch-effort) estimates. This study involved a fish-down of an abalone reef by commercial abalone divers.  Estimates of abalone abundance were made by applying the different methods before, during and after the fish-down.  The total catch (number of abalone harvested) was used as a bench-mark against which the differences between the before and after abundance estimates for each method could be compared.  In addition the precision for each method was estimated and compared.

Previously, the use of area-based transects was thought to be limited for estimating the abundance of spatially aggregated animals such as abalone.  However, the outcome of this study was that transect surveys are the preferred method because they accurately reflected absolute abundance, required a relatively small number of sampling days and were reasonably precise.  It is recommended that a stratified random approach be adopted when using transect sampling.  Timed-collections gave precise but inaccurate estimates of abundance which were somewhat more sensitive to diver (operator) effects.  CIR methods using transect data to estimate proportions can be as efficient as transect-based abundance estimates, however they require more intensive data collection.  If a cost-effective and quick tagging method can be identified, then a mark-recapture study will also work well, although a test for equal catchability of tagged and untagged animals should be included in the design of the experiment.  CIR analysis using timed collection data is less certain due to possible violation of equal catchability of two animal types, but will still give a workable result.  The use of catch and effort data as an index of abundance is not recommended for monitoring abalone abundance because, despite the controlled conditions during this study, estimates of abundance using these data could not be obtained in two out of three instances.

Future research should be directed towards a better understanding of the importance of aggregating behaviour in determining the impact of harvesting on blacklip abalone populations.  The involvement of commercial abalone divers is crucial to the success of these types of studies.  For this project, co-operation between managers, researchers and commercial divers was beneficial to all parties involved and it is hoped this will become a common occurrence in future research of the Victorian abalone fishery.

Related research

Communities
Blank
PROJECT NUMBER • 2023-200
PROJECT STATUS:
COMPLETED

Community Sentiment Survey

1. To collect and report on community perceptions, sentiment and likely purchasing and consumption behaviors relevant to the issues identified in this application.
ORGANISATION:
Intuitive Solutions
Environment

Interactions between the abalone fishery and sea urchins in NSW

Project number: 1993-102
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $374,612.44
Principal Investigator: Duncan Worthington
Organisation: Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (NSW)
Project start/end date: 14 Sep 1993 - 5 May 1999
Contact:
FRDC

Objectives

1. To quantify changes in the abundance of sea urchins and abalone on reefs in southern NSW
2. To describe the extent of the "barrens habitat" and the degree to which it is expanding on reefs in southern NSW
3. To describe the influence of habitat type on the abundance of abalone
4. To describe the effects of habitat type sea urchin density and harvest time on the quality of roe harvested from sea urchins
5. To gather preliminary data on the potential for a sustained fishery for this species in NSW

Final report

Author: Duncan Worthington
Final Report • 1999-02-15 • 3.67 MB
1993-102-DLD.pdf

Summary

A sampling method was developed to quantify changes in the abundance of abalone on reefs in NSW from Port Stephens to the Victorian border. The method is based on the repeated sampling of the same, fixed areas and has been used each year since 1994 to provide indices of the relative abundance of abalone of different sizes. The number and distribution of the fixed areas has been expanded each year since 1994. The relative abundance of small (<60 mm) and medium (<115 mm) abalone in NSW increased between 1994 and 1997. This information now provides an essential part of an annual stock assessment program for abalone in NSW, and is now funded by the NSW abalone industry.

A sampling program was developed to quantify changes in the abundance of sea urchins on reefs in NSW from Port Stephens to the Victorian border. The program is based on the use of random transects within Barrens habitat in a series of permanent sites to assess the abundance of sea urchins of different sizes. There was no evidence suggesting that the abundance of sea urchins (Centrostephanus rodgersii, hereafter Centrostephanus) increased in the four years of the present study. This duration of sampling is, however, unlikely to be sufficient to describe important changes in the abundance of sea urchins. For this reason, a comprehensive series of maps of the Barrens habitat were completed to provide a point-in-time estimate of its areal extent.

The extent of the Barrens habitat on reefs in NSW differed along the coast, but overall it represented approximately 50% (SE= 3.9) of the nearshore reef between Port Stephens and the Victorian border. Barrens were most dominant in Disaster Bay where the represented 68% (SE= 6.7) of the nearshore reef, but just south of there only l % (SE= 0.3) of the nearshore reef was Barrens. The time-scale of this study was not long enough to observe large-scale changes in the area of reef occupied by Barrens habitat, but a detailed baseline now exists for future comparison.

There was a strong influence of habitat on the abundance of abalone. Very few abalone were found in Barrens habitats, and abalone were most abundant in Fringe habitats. Manipulative experiments demonstrated that by reducing densities of Centrostephanus, Barrens habitat can be modified to alternative habitats that can enhance the recruitment, survival and growth of abalone. Such a strong negative interaction between an established high-value fishery, and an under-exploited resource with considerable potential for development, offers a rare opportunity to develop complimentary fishery management plans.

A variety of factors influenced the quality of Centrostephanus roe. The greatest yield of high quality roe was obtained from small urchins (60-80 mm) in the Fringe habitat during summer and autumn. Roe harvested from larger urchins, from the Barrens habitat, or during the spawning season, was generally of a poor quality. Because of the logistic difficulties and expense associated with processing sea urchin roe for markets, the fishery will need to consistently harvest roe of a high quality. Preliminary experiments suggested several techniques to enhance roe quality, in areas or times where it is poor, enabling the more reliable harvest of higher quality roe.

The development of the sea urchin roe fishery should be viewed within the larger context of their interaction with abalone, and the future of the abalone fishery. We recommend the further development of a management framework that facilitates an experimental approach to the management of both these fisheries. This approach should be carefully structured to allow both the development of a stock assessment program for sea urchins, and further research to help the development of the fishery. This would allow an increased sophistication in the management of both the sea urchin and abalone resources of NSW.

Keywords: Abalone, Haliotis rubra, Sea Urchins, Centrostephanus rodgersii, Stock Assessment, Competition, Recruitment, Abundance, Habitat, New South Wales, Australia.