NCCP: Development of strategies to optimise release and clean up strategies underpinning possible use of herpesvirus 3 (CyHV-3) for carp biocontrol in Australia

Project number: 2016-158
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $37,076.05
Principal Investigator: Luiz G. Silva
Organisation: Charles Sturt University (CSU) Bathurst
Project start/end date: 11 Jun 2017 - 10 Aug 2017
Contact:
FRDC

Need

Since the carp virus causes death within days to weeks of infection, the likely build-up of dead carp possess a potential hazard to water quality and aesthetic value of river ecosystems and human uses including drinking water, tourism and infrastructure needed to deliver public services. Therefore, the development of an effective strategy to deliver post-release clean-up activities will be critical to success. However, there is a need to establish a baseline of methods which would significantly contribute to the achievement of a successful clean-up procedure. The development of a plan to harvest large carp biomass from waterways will require strong methodological/practical basis to support and provide well-informed decisions for the different sectors involved on future clean-up activities.

The need for strong methodological basis drives the development of this project. Practical and science-based experiences on removal of dead fish from waterways are extant worldwide, but the information is not systematized. Certainly, various organizations amongst universities, fisheries (commercial/artisanal) and aquaculture as well as hydro and irrigation industries along the world have dealt with large mortality of fish requiring immediate action to reduce the likelihood of impacts on freshwater systems. Unfortunately, the methods/procedures used by them when necessary is not available, in most cases, in a systematized way. It is important to systematize this information and assess strengths and weaknesses of clean-up activities already conducted in order to develop a strong plan to be applied within the NCCP.

Objectives

1. Conduct a review of scientific and practical methods used worldwide to harvest large quantities of dead fish from waterways during mortality events.
2. Produce a report summarizing methods used, level of efficiency and effectiveness, strengths and limitations of potential carp clean-up methods, and advise on options most suitable for application in an Australian context for the removal of carp biomass from rivers, lakes, impoundments and wetlands.
3. Inform development of suitable clean-up strategy for different habitat types where carp virus might be released.
4. Provide inputs for other project from FRDC developing activities related to the NCCP, such as project 2016-132 (Benefit Cost Analysis).
5. Discuss with the Scientific Advisory Group (SAG) of the NCCP the merit of a trial to test clean-up strategies.

Final report

ISBN: 978-1-86-467312-8
Authors: Luiz G.M. Silva Keith Bell and Lee J. Baumgartner
Final Report • 2019-11-05 • 3.43 MB
2016-158-DLD.pdf

Summary

This study was undertaken by Charles Sturt University. Although there is a considerable knowledge gap in understanding the social-economic and environmental impacts of a fish kill, it is essential to recognise the risks associated with these events – especially water quality. In order to minimize these risks, clean-up procedures can be developed to remove excess of fish carcasses from waterways after a mortality event. However, clean-up is not a trivial task and may be dependent on various factors. Practical and science-based experiences on the removal of dead fish from waterways are extant worldwide, but the information is not systematised, when available. Therefore, this project aims to conduct a systematic review of methods and procedures adopted worldwide to remove fish carcases during large mortality events. 

Related research

Environment
Environment
Communities

NCCP: Socio-economic impact assessment and stakeholder engagement

Project number: 2018-189
Project Status:
Completed
Budget expenditure: $130,000.00
Principal Investigator: Jacki Schirmer
Organisation: University of Canberra
Project start/end date: 26 Feb 2019 - 29 Nov 2019
Contact:
FRDC

Need

The National Carp Control Plan (NCCP) will be delivered over a large geographic area in waterways used by, among others, thousands of farmers, fishers, tourists, boaters and nearby residents. Achieving support for the recommendations included in the NCCP requires assessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project will actively inform the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.

Objectives

1. Communication and engagement with stakeholders contributes to integration of stakeholder perspectives into development of the Plan
2. Potential socio-economic impacts of carp control are identified and implications for design of recommendations in the Plan identified
3. Stakeholder workshop successfully enables dialogue between stakeholders and scientists that results in better understanding of carp control challenges and opportunities
4. Discussion papers enable a wide range of stakeholders to access information about key considerations for carp control

Final report

ISBN: 978-0-6487600-0-9
Author: Jacki Schirmer
Final Report • 1.68 MB
2018-189-DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 2.64 MB
2018-189 Appendix 1 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 419.20 KB
2018-189 Appendix 2 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
 
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 565.38 KB
2018-189 Appendix 3 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
 
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 923.93 KB
2018-189 Appendix 4 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 523.68 KB
2018-189 Appendix 5 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 650.27 KB
2018-189 Appendix 6 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 554.49 KB
2018-189 Appendix 7 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 712.09 KB
2018-189 Appendix 9 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 864.90 KB
2018-189 Appendix 10 - DLD.pdf

Summary

This paper examines the potential social and economic impacts of controlling carp in Australia. As the National Carp Control Plan (NCCP) focuses on assessing the feasibility of releasing the carp virus, this paper also focuses on the potential impacts of virus release and whether and how these impacts could be mitigated.
 
Other carp control methods are referred to in the paper where they are relevant to understanding how impacts may differ depending on how carp control is implemented. The paper examines:
(i) What social and economic impacts are and how they are typically assessed at different stages of project development
(ii) The type of social and economic impact assessment (SEIA) focused on in this report: we focus on identifying how the recommendations of the NCCP could be designed to minimise negative and maximise positive impacts
(iii) The potential social and economic impacts (positive and negative) that could result from virus release, the circumstances in which they would be likely to occur, and recommendations for actions to reduce/prevent negative impacts and increase potential for positive impacts. 
Final Report • 2019-12-17 • 894.84 KB
2018-189 appendix 8 - DLD.pdf

Summary

The present study, undertaken by University of Canberra, was developed to investigate the potential to engender support for the recommendations included in the NCCP byassessing potential impacts of carp control on different groups, and ensuring key stakeholders are able to access, understand and have discussions about the science being used to inform the development of recommendations for the Plan. Through completing a program of assessment of socio-economic impacts, and enabling constructive engagement with stakeholders in NCCP communication and engagement actions, this project actively informed the design of both the communication and engagement used as part of developing the Plan, and the ultimate recommendations to government included in the Plan. This pro-active approach can enable design of a plan for carp control that incorporates actions that reduce potential for negative impacts and increase community trust in the process.